As the business world becomes more digital and mobile, the swords and shields used in litigation often take the form of electronically stored information. We frequently advise clients and remind opposing counsel to preserve all documents, including electronically stored information, when they reasonably know that litigation might ensue or as soon a potential claim is identified. (See In re Napster, Inc. Copyright Litigation (N.D.Cal. 2006) 462 F.Supp.2d 1060, 1067.) This advice may be addressed in a litigation hold letter. When parties fail to comply with California Code of Civil Procedure requirements to preserve documents related to litigation, a court may impose a costly penalty: precluding the party from prosecuting or defending the lawsuit. This penalty is called a “terminating sanction.”
In July, the United States District Court for the Southern District of California issued a terminating sanction against the plaintiff in NuVasive, Inc. v. Madsen Medical, Inc. (July 22, 2015) Case No. 13CV2077 BTM(RBB). The lawsuit involved NuVasive’s termination of a contract with Madsen Medical and NuVasive’s subsequent hiring of some of Madsen’s employees. Madsen filed a lawsuit in Nevada against the former employees, and filed counterclaims in the NuVasive lawsuit. NuVasive was aware of the potential litigation before filing its lawsuit and issued litigation holds to its employees in August 2012 and September 2013. The Court determined NuVasive did not take adequate steps to make sure its employees complied with the litigation hold.
Madsen argued that text messages from four NuVasive employees may have contained evidence of secret discussions related to the termination of Madsen Medical’s contract and hiring of Madsen’s sales personnel. NuVasive asked its employees to produce their smartphones for imaging, but one employee produced a newer phone (and later “wiped” the old one); another employee’s text messages were deleted, possibly as the result of an operating system upgrade; a third employee’s text messages were lost because he turned in his phone for an upgrade after the Madsen contract was terminated; and the fourth employee testified that he had deleted relevant text messages.
The court found that NuVasive destroyed evidence it had a duty to preserve and failed to enforce compliance with the litigation hold. The court also found that Madsen made a sufficient showing of prejudice by producing evidence that text messages were exchanged between the NuVasive employees and Madsen employees shortly before termination of the contract. These text messages referenced decisions by NuVasive about Madsen and assurances of support for the Madsen sales representatives and might have furthered Madsen Medical’s claims.
As a result of NuVasive’s failure to preserve the text messages on smartphones, the Court issued a sanction by formulating this instruction to the jury:
NuVasive has failed to prevent the destruction of evidence for MMI’s and Ms. Madsen’s use in this litigation after its duty to preserve the evidence arose. After considering all of the pertinent facts and circumstances, you may, but are not obligated to, infer that the evidence destroyed was favorable to MMI and unfavorable to NuVasive.
Ouch! This case illustrates that it may not matter whether an employer or employee owns the smartphone or device containing the relevant evidence. An employer with a Bring Your Own Device practice should develop a clear policy that requires employees to preserve and produce the devices they use in the course of employment when directed by the employer. This case also serves as a reminder that when issuing a litigation hold, employers must collect and preserve all information that may lead to discoverable information. This information includes not only paper documents but all potentially responsive electronically stored records — emails, text messages, chats, and voicemail recordings.
- Senior Counsel
Scott Sachs represents private and governmental entities in complex litigation in the areas of data privacy and security issues, construction and environmental law.
Mr. Sachs helps clients procure equipment, set up safety ...
- Partner
Lisa R. Allred specializes in education law, representing school districts, colleges, and universities, and applying her expertise in business, real estate, personnel, public works, technology, and intellectual property law ...
- Partner
Cathie Fields represents school districts, community college districts, and other educational agencies in labor and employment matters, general education issues, and governance matters. She advises clients on employment ...
Other AALRR Blogs
Recent Posts
- Retain or Delete? Managing Documents in the Digital Age
- “Juul” Vaporizers Trending Among Teenagers in Schools
- Study Highlights Security & Privacy Flaws in Public Educational Agency Websites
- A Renewed Focus on Title IX: Addressing Sexual Misconduct Allegations in the Educational Setting Amidst Hollywood Revelations
- Gun-Free School Zone Act Loophole Closed by Assembly Bill 424
- SB 395 — New Protections for Students Age 15 and under when Subjected to Custodial Interrogation by Law Enforcement
- EEOC’s Online Public Portal Goes Live
- New California Law Adds to List of Sex Offenses Affecting Teacher Credentialing and Employment
- U.S. Department of Education Launches New Student Privacy Website
- The Public Records Act Allows Agencies to Direct a Requester to Information Already Posted on the Agency’s Website, Furthering the Efficient Use of School Resources
Popular Categories
- (46)
- (76)
- (95)
- (52)
- (52)
- (39)
- (18)
- (40)
- (22)
- (1)
- (1)
- (7)
- (3)
- (4)
- (1)
Contributors
- Lisa R. Allred
- Christopher S. Andre
- Alan G. Atlas
- William M. Betley
- Mark R. Bresee
- W. Bryce Chastain
- Andreas C. Chialtas
- Gerald A. Conradi
- Georgelle C. Cuevas
- Michael J. Cullen
- Kevin R. Dale
- Scott D. Danforth
- Alexandria M. Davidson
- Mary Beth de Goede
- Anthony P. De Marco
- Peter E. Denno
- William A. Diedrich
- A. Christopher Duran
- Amy W. Estrada
- Jennifer R. Fain
- Eve P. Fichtner
- Cathie L. Fields
- Paul S. Fleck
- Jessica T. Gasbarro
- Karen E. Gilyard
- Todd A. Goluba
- Jacqueline D. Hang
- Davina F. Harden
- Martin A. Hom
- Andres C. Hurwitz
- Suparna Jain
- Darin K. Jones
- Jonathan Judge
- Tina L. Kannarr
- Warren S. Kinsler
- Michele A. Landenberger
- Hugh W. Lee
- Theodore Lieu
- Elizabeth P. Lind
- Kimberly C. Ludwin
- Bryan G. Martin
- Paul Z. McGlocklin
- Shawna M. McKee
- Stephen M. McLoughlin
- Anna J. Miller
- Marilou F. Mirkovich
- Joshua E. Morrison
- Kristin M. Myers
- Adam J. Newman
- Anthony P. Niccoli
- Aaron V. O'Donnell
- Sharon J. Ormond
- Gabrielle E. Ortiz
- Chesley D. Quaide
- Elizabeth J. Rho-Ng
- Todd M. Robbins
- Irma Rodríguez Moisa
- Joseph M. Rossini
- Alyssa Ruiz de Esparza
- Scott J. Sachs
- Marleen L. Sacks
- Gabriel A. Sandoval
- Peter A. Schaffert
- Constance J. Schwindt
- Allison M. Scott
- Justin R. Shinnefield
- Amber M. Solano
- David A. Soldani
- Terry T. Tao
- Constance M. Taylor
- Mark W. Thompson
- Lindsay A. Thorson
- Tiffany M. Tran
- Jonathan S. Vick
- Jabari A. Willis
- J. Scot Yarnell
- Elizabeth Zamora-Mejia
Archives
2018
2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- August 2016
- July 2016
- June 2016
- May 2016
- April 2016
- March 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
2015
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- July 2015
- June 2015
- May 2015
- April 2015
- March 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
2014
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
2013
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
2012
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012